Drowned Lake by Monumental Collab
2026-04-02
Tip: browser add-ons such as “YouTube Transcript Copy”, “Video Resumer” and “Tweaks for YouTube” add handy video features.
🎣 Drowned Lake Playtest: First-time UX review of this atmospheric survival horror fishing concept! 👇 Full developer feedback report & timestamps below!
Playtest Type: Blind (First-time player with zero prior knowledge). This mimics the real launch experience to see if players get confused and abandon the game early.
Focus areas: Onboarding clarity, UI/UX, game loop, pacing, and mechanics discovery.
In case you feel like you want to support me helping my cause: ☕ https://ko-fi.com/akton1
In case you like my reports and want me to playtest your game with additional care: https://ko-fi.com/akton1/commissions
🎬 Trailer & Presentation
liking the overall atmosphere and presentation immediately (00:01:05)
noticing blue GUI elements feeling out of place compared to the aesthetic (at first sight) maybe theyre too large? Or it needs to be more clear that they are camera/vhs gui. thats what they are right? or add the old TV screen effect (00:01:43)
appreciating start screen and character illustrations fitting the art style (00:02:11, 00:02:42)
feeling the VHS/blue visual effect is slightly overused (00:04:06)
Regarding the dialogue bubbles I realy like those, but also they feel a little bit too clean although they have the flackering effect, maybe could use rounded corners too..
⏱ First 5 Minutes Impression
enjoying dialogue box presentation early on (00:04:28)
being visually impressed by water and overall visuals (00:14:51)
noticing strong ambient sound design like wind and subtle horror tones (00:16:29, 00:17:02)
🧭 Onboarding, Goals & Feedback
not understanding writing/scribbling sounds initially (00:15:47)
later realizing it is tied to character journaling but unclear at first (00:17:46) (but it wasnt couse its on others too)
lacking explanations for mechanics and systems overall (00:39:06)
missing standard interaction keys like using E for dialogue (00:42:19)
not receiving explanations for items and their purpose (01:02:03)
🔥 Fun Factors & Peak Moments
In general defintely the atmosphere, visuals and sound of high quality.
discovering new mechanics creating moments of curiosity (00:23:10)
enjoying perspective switches, especially first-person camera usage (00:36:41, 00:53:52)
liking zoomed-in scale and immersion in certain views (00:44:06)
💡Ideas
wanting more interior exploration earlier in the game (00:30:30)
wishing for mouse scroll zoom functionality (00:44:12)
considering slower or more controlled camera movement for comfort (00:58:30)
wanting clearer introduction or integration of journal system (00:55:47)
hoping for stronger differentiation and payoff between characters (01:05:07)
🐞 Bugs / Crashes
no explicit bugs or crashes encountered
🎯 Game Loop & Motivation
understanding that characters have different tools and approaches (01:04:40)
recognizing a shared goal and narrative thread between characters (01:04:46)
feeling like mechanics and progression systems are only partially revealed early (01:00:30)
😴 Boredom Threshold
feeling early gameplay is slow with extended boat searching (00:30:30)
taking too long to get into meaningful interaction or progression (01:01:31)
not discovering enough gameplay variety within first 30 minutes (01:00:30)
👍What works well
strong atmosphere and cohesive visual identity (00:01:05, 00:14:51)
high-quality ambient audio enhancing immersion (00:16:29, 00:17:02)
dialogue presentation and character art fitting the tone (00:02:42, 00:04:28)
perspective switching adding variety and immersion (00:36:41, 00:53:52)
⚠️Biggest friction points
lack of onboarding and unclear mechanics early on (00:39:06, 01:02:03)
slow pacing and limited early gameplay variety (00:30:30, 01:00:30)
unclear purpose of items and progression systems (01:02:03)
UI/UX inconsistencies like missing standard controls (00:42:19)
some visual and camera effects feeling overused or uncomfortable (00:04:06, 00:58:30)
#indiegames #gamedev #playtest #uxdesign #indiedev #horrorgames #feedback #gamedesign
