Comatose by Lucky Dart
2026-03-27
Tip: browser add-ons such as “YouTube Transcript Copy”, “Video Resumer” and “Tweaks for YouTube” add handy video features.
🛠️ Comatose Blind Playtest: First-time UX, horror identity, and gameplay loop feedback on this atmospheric demo! 👇 Full developer feedback report & timestamps below!
Playtest Type: Blind (First-time player with zero prior knowledge). This mimics the real launch experience to see if players get confused and abandon the game early.
Focus areas: Onboarding clarity, UI/UX, game loop, pacing, and atmosphere consistency.
ℹ️🤖 Hi! I generate my report with the help of AI (from my subtitles) because - I want to cover more games and rather learn the speaking process then writing; also I think devs rather watch the gameplay experience anyways. In case there is anything unclear or you have specific questions ask in the comments below please! I make my reports free to get better at it and offer free feedback to indie devs.
In case you feel like you want to support me helping my cause: ☕ https://ko-fi.com/akton1
In case you like my reports and want me to playtest your game with additional care: https://ko-fi.com/akton1/commissions
🎬 Trailer & Presentation
feeling unsure how visuals/themes connect but still liking the style (00:00:50, 00:01:05)
noticing strong first impression from sound design and atmosphere (00:01:30)
perceiving the game as more advanced/polished than expected early on (00:02:04)
interpreting it as a showcase of interesting UI elements (00:02:41)
⏱ First 5 Minutes Impression
enjoying the mix of systems/ideas and overall feel early (00:07:22, 00:07:39)
feeling slightly overwhelmed needing to think through multiple mechanics (00:07:22)
liking music but immediately associating it with another well-known game (00:08:54)
questioning whether audio layering is intentional or consistent (00:09:03)
🧭 Onboarding, Goals & Feedback
feeling unclear about objectives or what messages are trying to communicate (00:27:03, 00:27:43)
wanting clearer feedback/messages on actions (e.g. usage, success states) (00:48:02)
not fully understanding progression requirements like items/resources (00:29:29, 00:31:10)
confusion about item usage/state changes (00:24:06, 00:24:17)
🔥 Fun Factors & Peak Moments
really enjoying enemy interaction/evasion moments (00:20:20)
appreciating the game opening up into exploration later (00:42:18)
liking the overall combination of mechanics and atmosphere (00:07:39)
💡Ideas
adding visible overview of off-screen inventory items (grid/row preview) (00:30:01)
reducing or differentiating elements that feel too close to other horror titles (music, UI, effects) (00:10:53, 00:42:53)
enhancing flashlight with more depth and physical feel (00:40:50, 00:41:12)
increasing impact of hit/knockback feedback (00:38:59)
improving clarity of interaction prompts during stressful moments (00:48:02)
🐞 Bugs / Crashes
noticing interactions that may not work as intended (00:17:45)
encountering broken/vanishing object behavior (00:24:17)
observing stuttering/laggy animations (00:19:02)
performance drops when many enemies are present (00:41:35)
🎯 Game Loop & Motivation
questioning incentive to engage enemies due to difficulty/reward imbalance (00:29:04)
unclear resource acquisition loop (e.g. screws origin/usage) (00:31:20)
gradual realization of exploration-based progression (00:42:37)
😴 Boredom Threshold
no strong boredom, but moments of confusion interrupting flow (general across 00:20:00–00:40:00)
👍What works well
strong atmosphere and sound design (00:01:30)
engaging enemy encounters and evasion feel (00:20:20)
sense of uniqueness despite familiar elements (00:10:06)
exploration opening up later feels rewarding (00:42:18)
⚠️Biggest friction points
unclear goals and messaging leading to confusion (00:27:03, 00:48:02)
UI/UX readability issues (inventory, item states) (00:24:06, 00:30:01)
elements feeling too derivative of other horror games (00:08:54, 00:10:53, 00:42:53)
visual/feedback polish gaps (flashlight, hit feedback, animations) (00:38:59, 00:40:50)
performance inconsistencies impacting experience (00:41:35)
#indiegames #gamedev #playtest #uxdesign #horrorgames #indiedev #gamefeedback #gamedevelopment #indiehorror #comatose
